Food fraud is the intentional creation of a mismatch between the declared and the actual characteristics of a food for economic gain. Turkish law defines two forms of that mismatch separately. Imitation means presenting a product as something it is not; adulteration means changing the product's composition. Imitation mostly happens on the packaging and in the declaration, adulteration inside the product, so the two are looked for with different methods.
How is food fraud defined?
The Knowledge Centre for Food Fraud and Food Quality at the European Commission's Joint Research Centre relies on the definition in CEN Workshop Agreement 86: food fraud is the intentional creation of a mismatch between the claims made about a product and its actual characteristics. The Knowledge Centre also describes the same phenomenon as misrepresenting a food's origin, composition or method of preparation in order to gain by deceiving the customer.
The definition has three elements: intent, economic gain and deception. Intent separates fraud from an accidental quality deviation. The gain element explains why fraud concentrates on expensive products whose contents cannot be judged by eye.
What is the difference between imitation and adulteration?
Law No. 5996 on Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed defines the two concepts separately:
- Adulteration (tağşiş): removing all or part of the components and nutritional values that give a product its essential character contrary to the legislation, changing their quantity, or adding another substance that does not carry the same value in place of that substance as if it were the same. Adding another vegetable oil to olive oil or adding syrup to honey are typical examples.
- Imitation (taklit): presenting a product, in terms of form, composition and properties, as if it had characteristics it does not have, or as if it were identical to another product. Labelling a lower-grade product as a higher grade or copying the appearance of a well-known product falls under this heading.
In practice the two often appear together, because an adulterated product is usually sold under the genuine product's label. The reason to keep them apart is that the question to answer is different. With imitation, what is examined is whether the product comes from the source it claims. With adulteration, the question is whether the product contains what is declared.
Does every nonconformity count as fraud?
No. What separates adulteration from a quality defect is intent. An oil that has deteriorated because it was stored badly, or a product that misses the expected values because of harvest conditions, is not adulteration in itself.
That does not release the business from responsibility. Article 24 of Law No. 5996 separately prohibits labelling and presenting food in a way that misleads the consumer. Article 40 attaches a separate administrative sanction to a mismatch between the label declaration and the product's content and analytical values. Whether or not there was intent, the business is responsible for any gap between what the label says and what is inside the product.
What are the types of food fraud?
The Knowledge Centre classifies food fraud under these headings:
- Dilution: extending a valuable ingredient with a cheaper substance.
- Substitution: replacing an ingredient, or the whole product, with a lower-value alternative.
- Concealment: interfering with the product to hide low quality or a defect.
- Mislabelling: false declarations about origin, species, grade or content.
- Unapproved enhancement: adding non-permitted substances to improve the product's appearance or measured values.
- Counterfeiting: copying a brand's product.
- Grey market production, theft and diversion: unauthorised production of the product or its diversion into unauthorised channels.
Dilution, substitution, concealment and unapproved enhancement touch the product's composition. None of these four can be seen by looking at the packaging or the documents. Counterfeiting, diversion and part of mislabelling, by contrast, can be traced through packaging, documents and distribution records.
How are imitation and adulteration inspected in Türkiye?
Under Article 24 of Law No. 5996, imitation and adulteration of food and feed are prohibited. A provision added in 2020 also states explicitly that an imitated or adulterated product may not be processed or placed on the market. Under Article 40, such products are seized and recalled from the market at the expense of the responsible party. The operator who produces, imports or places the product on the market under its own name, and the retailer who sells it without ensuring traceability, are given an administrative fine proportional to annual gross revenue.
Article 31 of the Law authorises the Ministry to share information obtained through official controls with the public. Since 2 October 2024, the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry has published products found to be imitated or adulterated electronically as soon as the finding is final. The records appear in the "Gıda Kamuoyu Duyurusu" (public food announcement) section at guvenilirgida.tarimorman.gov.tr, under the headings "Taklit ve Tağşiş Yapılan Gıdalar" (imitated and adulterated foods) and "Sağlığı Tehlikeye Düşürecek Gıdalar" (foods that endanger health). Each record gives the announcement date, company, brand, product, nonconformity and batch or serial number.
These lists are a resource for buyers as much as for consumers. A business buying raw materials can regularly search them for its suppliers' names and the numbers of the batches it bought. Responsibility does not stay with one link in the chain: a packer placing a product on the market under its own brand also answers for adulteration in the raw material it bought from a supplier.
How are imitation and adulteration looked for?
For imitation, verifying the packaging, the label and the source comes first; a mark applied to the product can show in the field whose product it is. For adulteration, the product's composition has to be measured. When each approach is the right choice is covered in marking or analysis, and the methods used to detect adulteration, along with the split between screening and the laboratory, in Molevex's post how is food adulteration detected.
Deeptrace's food solutions work on the measurement side. Molevex measures a product's composition without adding anything to it, compares it with a reference accepted as genuine and confirms the result in the laboratory. For products that need a decision at the moment of purchase, Olivex assesses the purity and quality grade of olive oil and Beevex whether honey contains added syrup, on the spot, with an analysis set and a phone. These measurements do not replace official controls or official laboratory analysis.
We describe which checks make sense at which point in food and beverages on our food and beverage industry page.
Sources
- Law No. 5996 on Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed (Articles 3, 24, 31, 40), in Turkish
- European Commission, Knowledge Centre for Food Fraud and Food Quality: Food fraud
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Taklit ve Hileli Gıda Listeleri Artık Anlık Paylaşılacak, 1 October 2024, in Turkish
- Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Güvenilir Gıda: public food announcements, in Turkish


