Product authentication means testing, on the product itself, whether the item in your hands is the product it is claimed to be. Traceability keeps a record of where a product came from and where it went in the chain; identification gives the product a unique name such as a serial number or a QR code. Both feed authentication with data, but neither proves on its own that a product is genuine. The record can be complete and the code readable while the product next to the record has been swapped.
How are the three concepts defined?
The Anti-Counterfeiting and Anti-Piracy Technology Guide of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) sorts the technologies in this field into three groups by what they do:
- Authentication: the process by which the claimed identity and attributes of a product are verified.
- Tracking/tracing: determining the intended, current or past locations of a unique item along the supply chain.
- Anti-tampering: a mechanism that prevents meddling with a product in order to alter, falsify or otherwise interfere with it.
Identification is the infrastructure under all three. The EU Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR) defines a unique product identifier as a unique string of characters that identifies a product and also enables a web link to its digital product passport. The barcode, two-dimensional symbol or similar element that carries the identifier is called a data carrier.
What separates the three concepts is the question each one asks:
- Identification asks "what is this product called?" and relies on a serial number, QR code or batch number. On its own it does not prove that the product behind the code is genuine.
- Traceability asks "where did this product come from and where did it go?" and relies on purchase and sales records. On its own it does not prove that the product on record is the one in hand.
- Authentication asks "is this the product it claims to be?" and relies on a signature added to the product or on its measured composition. On its own it does not show which route the product took through the chain.
What does the law require for traceability?
In food, traceability is an obligation. Türkiye's Law No. 5996 on Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed defines traceability as the ability to trace and follow food, feed and substances intended to be in food through all stages of production, processing and distribution. Under Article 24 of the Law, food and feed business operators must set up a system that makes this tracking possible and provide the information to the Ministry on request. Food placed on the market must also be labelled or identified in a way that allows traceability.
In the EU the same principle sits in Article 18 of the General Food Law, Regulation (EC) No 178/2002. A business must be able to show who supplied a product and to whom it was supplied, and make this available to the competent authorities on demand. In practice this is called the "one step back, one step forward" principle.
The scope of the obligation is clear: it asks for records, not for testing what is inside the product. A batch can be adulterated while every change of hands has been recorded in full. Traceability then helps find the link where the problem started; what is inside the batch is shown by measurement.
What do serial numbers and QR codes prove?
Reading a code shows that the code is registered in a system. That is all it says about the product. The code is printed on a label, and labels can be copied. If the code of a genuine product is printed on counterfeit packaging, the person scanning it sees the same record.
Tracking systems close part of this gap. The same code being read at two distant points at the same time points to a copy. Even so, that does not say which item is genuine. Nor does the code tell you anything about the content: a bottle filled with a different oil on the filling line reaches the shelf with its own genuine code.
Codes and records are therefore inputs to authentication. The code is what ties an authentication result to a batch and a date, but the code is not what produces the result.
How is a product authenticated?
The international framework for choosing authentication methods is ISO 22383:2020. The standard gives guidelines for performance criteria and an evaluation methodology for authentication solutions that aim to establish the authenticity and integrity of material goods throughout their life cycle. It was published in 2020 and replaced ISO 12931:2012. According to ISO's summary, an organisation uses these criteria to decide which authentication elements it needs after carrying out a counterfeiting risk assessment. The standard does not set economic criteria linking performance to cost.
The EUIPO guide also sorts authentication elements by how they are inspected:
- Overt: discernible to the average person without tools or training, and difficult to reproduce, such as a tamper seal.
- Covert: not immediately discernible to the average person, and visible only with additional tools or training.
There are two ways to test the product itself. In one, a signature that can only be read under the right condition is added to the product or its packaging; the signature shows whose product it is. In the other, nothing is added; the composition is measured and compared with a reference accepted as genuine, and the measurement shows what the product is. When each route is chosen is covered in marking or analysis, and how the reference is built in what is a reference measurement.
Which question needs which tool?
When the concepts are used interchangeably, the wrong tool gets chosen. Depending on where the problem lies, the split looks like this:
- Recall and liability: finding where a problem batch went is a traceability task.
- Diversion: a product made for one market turning up in another channel is followed through identification and tracking records.
- Counterfeits: a fake entering the channel from outside is separated out by reading a signature added to the product.
- Adulteration and content that does not match the label: cannot be seen without measuring the product's composition. The types of food fraud are covered in what is food fraud.
In a sound setup the three work together. The code identifies the batch, the record shows its route, and the authentication result is recorded against the same batch number. In a complaint or a dispute, both the route and the product sit in the same file.
Where does Deeptrace fit in this split?
Deeptrace works on the authentication side and follows two routes: it adds to the product a signature that is only read under the right condition, or it measures the product's composition without adding anything and compares it with a reference accepted as genuine. Because every reading and measurement is recorded with its batch number, the result can be matched with the business's existing traceability records. These measurements do not replace official controls or accredited laboratory analysis. The methods are described on the technologies page.
Frequently asked questions
Can a product with a QR code be fake?
Yes. A QR code shows that the product is linked to a record. If the code is copied and printed on counterfeit packaging, scanning it still brings up the same record. Showing that the product is genuine requires testing a signature added to the product or the product's composition.
Does a business that meets its traceability obligation authenticate its products?
No. Law No. 5996 and Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 require a record of who the product was bought from and sold to. The record does not show that the content matches the label. The two tasks complement each other, but one does not replace the other.
What is the difference between identification and authentication?
Identification gives a product a unique name; authentication tests whether the product carrying that name is the product it claims to be. Identification works through a label or data carrier; authentication looks at the product itself or at a signature added to it.
Which standard applies when choosing an authentication solution?
The international reference is ISO 22383:2020. It proposes criteria and a method for evaluating the performance of solutions and expects the choice to follow a counterfeiting risk assessment. It contains no cost criteria. Check ISO's page for the current version.
Sources
- EUIPO, Anti-Counterfeiting and Anti-Piracy Technology Guide: Glossary
- ISO 22383:2020, Guidelines for the selection and performance evaluation of authentication solutions for material goods
- ISO 12931:2012 (withdrawn, replaced by ISO 22383:2020)
- Law No. 5996 on Veterinary Services, Plant Health, Food and Feed (Articles 3 and 24), in Turkish
- Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, General Food Law (Articles 3 and 18)
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1781, Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (Article 2)


