Rapid test or accredited lab? What a field result is worth in a food inspection or dispute

A rapid test does not replace laboratory analysis in an official food inspection, but it can drive purchasing decisions and support a dispute file. Which result counts where, and what to put in the contract.

In an official food inspection, what counts is the analysis of the inspector's sample by a ministry or ministry-approved laboratory; a company's own rapid test does not replace it. Commercial relationships work differently: the parties can write a field measurement into their contract as an acceptance criterion, while in a dispute the last word usually goes to a laboratory report and a court expert. The real value of a field measurement is separating the right batch at the right moment and tying the route to the laboratory to a record.

Where does a rapid test stand in an official inspection?

Turkish law serves as the worked example here. Under Article 33 of Law No. 5996, official control samples are analysed in ministry laboratories or in laboratories the ministry has approved. A laboratory may not issue a report for an analysis it has not been approved for. An amendment to the Regulation on Food Control Laboratories on 1 August 2024 added a further duty: laboratories must be accredited for the official control analyses the ministry designates.

Under Article 12 of the Regulation on Official Controls of Food and Feed, the inspector normally takes two sets of samples. One goes for analysis and the other is held as a retained sample; on request, a third set stays with the operator. The operator can object within seven days of notification, and the result on the retained sample is final. There is no right of objection for foods with under seven days of shelf life, for microbiological tests, or where there is too little product to analyse a retained sample.

One detail is easily missed: a report you commission yourself, even from an accredited laboratory, does not stand in for the official result either. The Regulation on Food Control Laboratories classes samples submitted for quality control, verification or pre-export checks as "private request samples" and places their results among analyses that do not form the basis of an inspection.

A rapid test helps only indirectly. Article 22 of the law requires operators to meet the legal conditions, verify that they do and keep records up to date. A batch-linked measurement record gives that duty substance and shows which batches a finding affects. It is not a defence or an exemption in itself.

Is an accredited laboratory always required?

No. It depends on where the result will be used.

SituationWhat decidesRole of a rapid test
Official controlMinistry or approved laboratory; accreditation for designated analysesNone directly; stays as an internal record
Objection to an official resultAnalysis of the retained sampleNone; records show which batch is affected
Purchasing and supplier relationsContract and specificationCan drive accept, suspect or reject decisions
CourtThe court's assessment and expert examinationSupporting record
ExportThe buyer's specificationPre-shipment screening; a report is usually requested as well

On the export side, the spice guidance from CBI, the Dutch government's centre for promoting imports, says European buyers ask for documentation from ISO/IEC 17025 accredited laboratories, that it should be no older than six months, and that the laboratory and test methods should be agreed with the buyer.

Is a field result evidence in a commercial dispute?

Turkish law neither bars a field measurement as evidence nor makes it conclusive. Four articles of the Code of Civil Procedure frame the question:

  • Article 193: The parties may agree in writing that certain facts will be proven with certain evidence. This is the basis for a clause saying "this measurement at delivery, this laboratory in a dispute". An evidence agreement that makes it impossible or extremely difficult for one party to prove its case is invalid.
  • Article 266: Where a question needs special or technical knowledge, the court turns to an expert.
  • Article 293: The parties may obtain a scientific opinion from a specialist of their own.
  • Article 400: Where evidence may be lost or become hard to present, its preservation can be requested before a lawsuit. This matters for a perishable batch or one about to enter a blend.

The most tangible contribution of a field measurement is timing. Under Article 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code, in a sale between merchants a defect that is obvious on delivery must be notified within two days. If it is not obvious, the buyer must inspect the goods or have them inspected within eight days and notify any defect found within that period. For a defect that an ordinary inspection cannot reveal, Article 223 of the Code of Obligations applies: notify as soon as it is discovered. A buyer who separates a suspect batch without waiting for the laboratory and gives notice in time has taken the step needed to preserve its rights. How a result will be weighed in a specific dispute is a question for legal counsel.

What belongs in the contract?

Most disputes come from a criterion never written down. A supply contract should answer these points:

  1. Which parameter is measured at delivery, and by which method.
  2. Which value ranges mean accept, suspect and reject.
  3. Who takes the sample, how many sets are kept, how they are sealed and labelled, and where and for how long they are stored.
  4. Which laboratory and method apply in a dispute, and whether the result binds the parties. Check the laboratory's approval and accreditation scope first: accreditation covers specific tests, not the whole laboratory.
  5. How and within what period a defect must be notified.

What makes a field record useful?

The flow should be field reading, decision, retained sample, laboratory if needed, then contract or inspection file. Each reading should carry the batch number, date and time, operator, method, result, decision and retained sample label.

The limits matter too. A rapid method answers the question it was designed for and may miss another form of adulteration. A result describes only the sample measured, so whether it represents the batch matters as much as the measurement. A "suspect" result means separating the batch and sending it for confirmation; an "acceptable" one should not be presented as a laboratory report. Method choice is covered in reference measurement.

Where do Deeptrace's measurements fit?

Olivex and Beevex assess olive oil and honey at the point of purchase with a field kit and a phone camera. Molevex compares a product's composition with a reference accepted as genuine and confirms it in the laboratory where needed. Measurements are recorded with the batch number and support audit and export files; laboratory results prevail for official certification. Control points in food are described on our food and beverage industry page.

Sources

Meeting request

The right method for your product comes from the product itself.

The first meeting reviews your product group, your production flow and the points where verification will take place, and recommends a marking or analysis method.

Request a meeting